I downloaded both files..

sound quality-wise, full metal's was a lot clearer although his wasn't all that great either

full metal: good grooving in the beginning.. are you using a double bass? I also liked the transitions to the different parts of the solo.. a nice array of chops with some solid feel.. what band do you play for?

gyutea: your audio was really cloudy and it's really hard to make out what you're doing. but from what I could hear, you had a solid groove going but your transitioning was not as smooth as full metal. Also some parts were a bit shaky on rhythm. And at the end, you could have been doing something crazy that may have won you this battle, but we can't hear it.. soooo

my vote goes to : full metal