My 2c, what you are using sounds o.k for warm and deep. The
Evans G2 coated i have used are warm, i have also used similar sounding
Aquarian double thins coated which were great heads. Tune them looser for fatter sound or depth.I think pinstripes are too muffled for live work unless miked (or you hit hard), and hydraulics only for miking/recording (or toned down practice kit).
I currently use on the toms
Remo Emperors with G2 clear reso's which make the drums nice and alive, and speak well for live gigging.
Snare i use either Powerstroke 3's or
Aquarian coated both with powerdot on inside and they are reasonably warm and deep, mind i have a wood shell which gives that warmth.
Kick i concentrate on punch, which i get from Superkick 2 and ported front head, so warmth not an issue. Perhaps muffling slightly, a small towel rolled up and touching both or one head will give you some depth and warmth by taking away the ring. I find not necessary from a distance as the ring blends in, depends on head choice tuning as well..
I find the
Aquarian heads that i have used excellent, just put them on, tune and go.
How do you find those Response 2's Blake, they look like ones i could use (too many choices)

?
http://www.ruppsdrums.com/Drum_Heads..._drum_he.shtml